Okay, this is gunna be a LONG blog post. I have to cover the reason for the post as well as addressing the content of the title itself, so there’s a bit of material to cover.
I apologise in advance. Maybe I’ll split it into two posts and save everyone’s eyes. (EDIT: yeah, I’m gunna do that).
On to the blog post.
It was at an extended family gathering roughly a year and a half ago; I didn’t know everyone, and not everyone knew me. My sister introduced me to someone as an author.
Their response?
“Oh, you make a living out of lying!”
I’d like to say it was the first time I’ve had a response like that, but it wasn’t. It stung, but it wasn’t the first, and it wasn’t the worst.
Nor, unfortunately, was it the last.
I’ve been accused of everything from being a liar to dishonouring God; asked anxiously if I’m sure what I’m doing is something a Christian should waste their time on; accused of writing things that belong in Dark Mofo (an outspokenly anti-christian festival that specialises in blasphemy and anything that is an art form that speaks against Christ).
The latest of these occasions came in the form of a series of Facebook private messages through my author page, and prompted me to think again about this blog post that I’d meant to write at least a year ago.
I’d recently been invited to read and speak at a Christian arts festival that I attended last year as a guest; I knew that someone had found offence with my work and was trying to insist on my not being allowed to read. When the organisers mentioned the concerns had been brought up, I asked them if they’d like me to read from a different book instead, just to keep everybody happy. There was no thought in my mind that there was anything wrong with BETWEEN JOBS, just that it was better to make life as easy for the organisers as possible. One book for another–no big deal.
Unfortunately, the person who had objected wasn’t content even with me reading from another book and approached me through FB messenger on my author page.
The first message was more or less polite, apart from an accusation and an insinuation that were something of a slap in the face. They concluded their message with a demand to know why I wrote it [BETWEEN JOBS]. Why was it necessary? They wanted to enter into a dialogue with me about how a person who seemed to be sincere about their Christian faith, could write books with magic in them.
As I read the message, I prayed for wisdom in how to respond–as a matter of fact, I’d been praying just that morning for grace to respond to unpleasant people in kindness and not in pride, so I suppose it was timely. (And lest anyone think it was an excess of godly thinking that had me praying like that, let me tell you, you’re dead wrong. It’s because I failed spectacularly badly with something slightly similar just a week ago. God being the God He is toward me, He obviously decided to repeat the lesson.)
I swallowed the hurt of the accusation and the insinuation, and tried to remember that this person had represented themselves as a Christian, and that although they had no right to dictate what I wrote, or my conscience before God, they had every right to speak up if they felt their conscience led them to say something.
I didn’t want to answer in wounded pride, or hurt someone who was genuinely concerned for my soul. So I wrote back politely, letting them know I appreciated their concern for my soul; that I was completely whole in my conscience regarding my writing; that I was indeed serious about honouring God in all that I did; that I didn’t consider by writing about magic or murder, that I was dishonouring God. I told them I had prayed for many years over my decision to write as a job, and hoped by this they would understand that although our positions differed, we would have to agree to disagree and serve God in our own ways the best we could.
The next message from this person was considerably pushier; it demanded to know was I sure I was right in my conscience, and didn’t my changing the book I was going to read from mean that I was secretly feeling guilty about the book?
It contained several guilt-inducement attempts that I recognised only through having lived with a manipulator for the past ten years. It spoke of anger that something like my work would be read in a Christian festival, and tried to insinuate that there was trouble or misunderstanding between the organisers of the festival and myself. In short, it looked like the author was trying to talk me out of attending the festival, having failed to have me disinvited by the organisers.
I replied to let them know that I wouldn’t be discussing the matter with them, since I didn’t find it a profitable use of time given our vastly differing stances, and that I wasn’t in the kind of health that made debating over the internet a pleasant or sustainable pastime.
I thanked them again for their care for my soul, and concluded with the comfort that if God saw fit to show me that I was wrong, it would be accomplished in His time and through His Spirit, and asked that they be content with that.
Their final message didn’t even attempt any concern. This time, instead of opening with anything remotely appropriate (an acknowledgement that they would honour my request, or an agreement–no matter how reluctant–to leave God’s work to God) they accused either myself or the organisers of the festival of lying, and suggested I be very sure there weren’t any problems.
Having checked with the organisers that they were still very happy to have me attend as a speaker/reader, I turned my thoughts to considering what I consider every time I experience a reaction like this: the reasons I write what I write, and what I hope to accomplish in the act of writing as well as the books produced thereby.
To Be Continued in Part Two: Why I Write What I Write, or, The Actual Blog Post…
Ugh. What an unpleasant experience!!! I’m so glad that you were able to keep open and honest communication with the event organisers.
And yes, I’ve also been on the receiving end of some very insensitive/accusatory comments myself. Good on you for dealing with it graciously!
Honestly, I feel bad about taking praise for this kind of thing, because there are so many times I don’t deal with them graciously; and those times far outweigh the ones where I do…
Yes, I’m sure you’ve had more than your fair share of comments–seeing that you write not just fiction but a fair bit of non fiction/blog posts/stuff that people love to get touchy about (aka, History and Religion)!
You write whatever you want to write. It is pushy narrow minded people, like that person that wrote to you, that make others think twice about religion. Don’t let them upset you, it’s probably what they enjoy.
As with other things in the writerly life, I’m progressively learning not to let things bother me. It’s just that sometimes I’m progressing better than at other times… 😀
You are a wonderfully talented author and I love that you wrote this post. I too have been feeling the need to write such a post. Someone will always disagree and push their negativity and personal beliefs. But when you have so clearly reflected and are so open to God, good on you to stand by your beliefs. Your writing is light to others. Thank you for being so strong!
*blush*
Now I just have to finish the other half (the REAL blog post, lol!)
I do try to write in a way I feel honours God, but even if I wasn’t deliberately trying to do that–people’s worldviews come through in their writing, you know?
I’ll be interested to see what you write on the subject =)
Ugh. Some people! I would imagine that it might be hard not to take such bilge personally, no matter what you tell yourself. Please know that there are plenty of us who love your work and believe that anti – Christian is definitely not on the list of words to describe your writing. Keep up the good work and Illegitimi non carborundum as Virgil never said.
It sometimes is hard not to take it personally, since writing is a very personal thing; but I’m learning to deal with it better every time (I hope!)
I giggled at the non-Virgil “quote” and then googled it to make sure my translation was correct. Then I giggled a bit more because it was 😀
I’m glad it made you giggle 😁. It’s a fairly common, bastard Latin, pseudo highbrow, tongue in cheek, quote here.
Love me some pseudo highbrow Latin! 😀 😀 😀
Now you made me giggle!
Wow. I sincerely hope that this unpleasant interaction does not change the way you write. I am a Christian and am often appalled at some of the things said and done in the name of Christianity by people who need to feel that they are better than someone else. I also loved Between Jobs and can’t wait for the next installment.
No; I wouldn’t change the way I write for someone else’s opinion. Only God’s leading could do that; if I were convinced that I was actually doing something wrong. In the meantime, I make blog posts to work out my thoughts and find that there are more than a few of us who cop this sort of interaction a lot…
Thank you =)
Someone condemned you for being a Christian who wrote about magic? They must really hate C.S. Lewis and Tolkien.
The worst I got was an email from someone who said I was wasting my God-given talent and would I please write for some other Christian Romance publisher so she wouldn’t have to risk reading another of my books.
*open mouth*
*blink*
*close mouth*
What?? How rude! If they think like that, they could just, yanno, not read your book! No need email you and tell you that….
*fumes silently*
And yes; this person didn’t care for either C.S. Lewis or Tolkien, either, apparently…
“Pharisees” tend to be hateful, judgmental people, and have their own standards that only those of like-mind can live up to (supposedly). You were gracious, patient and kind, a very good example of your Master. I’m glad I found this blog . I’ve thoroughly enjoyed your books ever since discovering them sometime after the first of the year, and now know why they have been so “clean” to read, yet never lacking in story. Bless you!
I’m so glad you’ve been enjoying the books! I delight in writing them, so it’s nice to know other people are delighted too =)